• Home
  • Contact
FICCI blog
  • Home
  • Contact
Home  /  Domestic Economy  /  Gaar is subjective & gives arbitrary powers to tax authorities
ficci, federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry

Gaar is subjective & gives arbitrary powers to tax authorities

Written by
Domestic Economy GAAR, india, reforms, tax 1 Comment
Share this..
Twitter0
Facebook0
LinkedIn0

We are concerned about the manner in which general anti-avoidance rules (Gaar) may be applied. We welcome the Prime Minister’s intervention to set up an expert panel chaired by Parthasarathi Shome to frame the guidelines on Gaar.

Many countries have such a framework, but we need to tread carefully in its implementation. The formulation of rules here is a complex process. Though Gaar is now part of the I-T Act, government should move cautiously and ensure that it does not hurt growth and investment.

Gaar empowers tax authorities to invalidate any arrangement if it is entered into by the assessee with the objective of obtaining a tax benefit. It is subjective in nature. Tax officials would have wide-ranging powers to declare any arrangement as ‘an impermissible avoidance arrangement’.

Certainty and stability form the basic foundation of any fiscal system. Gaar provisions, in their present form, would introduce uncertainty in terms of tax implications of various business and non-business arrangements. Business decisions are made on a real-time basis. If the revenue department were to sit on judgment in hindsight, it would introduce considerable uncertainty.

One of the main worries with Gaar, in its present form, is that the onus is on the assessee to prove that tax benefit is not the main purpose of an impugned arrangement. An anti-abuse provision that shifts the burden of proof on the assessee goes against the fundamental principle of ‘innocent unless proven guilty’.

Another concern for foreign investors is the applicability of tax treaties. India, which is looking at significant inflows of capital, cannot sacrifice growth at the altar of tax revenues. Under no circumstances should Gaar override the tax treaties.

The guidelines on Gaar should leave no room for ambiguity in its application. This can be achieved only if we have a large number of examples specifying where Gaar can or cannot be invoked. A review mechanism at the finance minister’s level to ensure that Gaar is invoked as an exception rather than a rule and only in deserving cases would help. Ideally, Gaar should become specific anti-avoidance rule.

This post is written by Mr RV Kanoria, Past President, FICCI (2012). It originally appeared in The Economic Times on July 20, 2012

 Previous Article Strengthening Healthcare Sector in India
Next Article   Universal Healthcare: Dream or Reality – FICCI Heal 2012

Related Posts

  • India’s Renewable Sector: The Show Must Go On

  • Indian Insurance Industry: Mega Trends to Watch Out For

  • Trends in StartUp Ecosystem and Financing

1 Comment

  1. M.Srinivas Kumar
    July 24, 2012 at 11:38 AM

    Well articulated.

  • Popular Posts
  • Recent Posts
  • Direct Selling – An Avant-garde Model
  • A Billion+ Customers need a Million Sales and Service Touch Points
  • Changing Times for Mining and Steel Sector in India Post COVID 19
  • Insurance Jobs of the Future
  • Massive potential for farmers, consumer by strengthening millet value chain; Let’s strive to put ‘Millets on every plate’
  • Energizing travel towards a sustainable future
  • Mining for a Green Future- What Lies Ahead
  • Technology transfer and collaboration – an important tool in enhancing the healthcare ecosystem

Drop us a line..

February 2023
M T W T F S S
« Jan    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728  

FICCI Tag Cloud

banking budget business business confidence CAPAM 2017 Knowledge Paper capital markets Changing Face of Insurance crime direct selling economic relations economy economy insights Economy of Jobs economy watch education environment FDI ficci finance financial foresights fintech growth GST healthcare homeland security india industry innovation insurance MSME oil opec policy policy reforms RBI reforms retail skills Skills for All SME survey technology UK universal basic income women
   Get Updates via RSS Feed

   FICCI website

Social Media

  • Connect on Facebook
  • Connect on Twitter
  • Connect on LinkedIn
  • Connect on Instagram
  • Connect on YouTube

Archives

Popular Posts

  • Energizing travel towards a sustainable future
  • Mining for a Green Future- What Lies Ahead
  • Massive potential for farmers, consumer by strengthening millet value chain; Let’s strive to put ‘Millets on every plate’
© Copyright 2018. FICCI.